When searching for a new home, buyers have a lot of ideas about what they are looking for, from the layout to the design elements and even materials and finishes. In order to get an idea of what homebuyers are looking for, homebuilder Ashton Woods asked future homebuyers about their preferences in builders, builder options and design and layout elements.

Overall, participants said they are looking for more space than they currently have. Homes with three bedrooms and two bathrooms tended to be favored overall. But baby boomers were more likely to want four bedrooms, whereas millennials were looking for three-bedroom homes the most, followed by two-bedroom homes.

The survey found that nearly half of future homebuyers are currently the most frustrated with their kitchen (46 percent), followed by the master bathroom (32 percent) and the backyard (30 percent). The garage, master bedroom and secondary bathrooms are also frustration points for more than 20 percent of participants.

“I think one of the biggest mistakes people can make when buying or designing a home is they are looking for a style of cabinet or color of cabinet. They may get that, but they miss thinking about how they are going to live in the space and utilize it,” said Leigh Spicher, the national director of design studios at Ashton Woods. “They haven’t accounted for where they might want to store knives or where to store large cookie sheets or appliances. They have these beautiful cabinets on the outside but don’t have an organization strategy to use the space. Then when you’re there, it becomes frustrating.”

These frustrations speak to what buyers are willing to splurge on. Nearly three-fourths of participants said they would prioritize luxury features in the kitchen over any other part of their home. And while all-white kitchens have seen a resurgence in many design circles, homebuyers actually said they prefer natural wood over white cabinets (30 percent versus 17 percent).

“What they’re looking for is more finishes with character,” Spicher said. “We’re seeing this across different types of finishes in the home, some type of story or character to the pieces, which moves them away from white.”

When it comes to the master suite, the size of the bedroom was the most important feature for 44 percent of survey participants, followed by the location of the master suite within the floorplan. However, size isn’t as important in the master bathroom and the closet space, as only 10 percent of respondents said they gave much thought to the size of those two features.

What buyers do care about with their bathroom is having a walk-in shower and no bathtub (37 percent) or having a separate shower and tub (36 percent) more than having a shower/tub combination (27 percent).

Read more from our New Construction Issue:

• Cover story: Marketing new construction
• New construction lots shrink while homes grow
• Survey: Challenges agents face selling new construction
• Agent Snapshot: Eric Rollo, Realtor, William Raveis Real Estate

The extras

• The most important extra feature for homebuyers is a dedicated laundry room, with 81 percent of participants wanting that space over a home office (67 percent) or an entertainment room (59 percent).
• A hobby room is also considered valuable, but up to a certain price. A third of participants were willing to spend an extra $10,000 for the space, but 24 percent said they were not willing to spend any extra money on it.
• Extra space is not just for the human members of the household. Almost half of participants who owned a pet said having a dedicated space for their pet was important to them.

Home style preferences

• When it came to the general build of a home, homebuyers have pretty diverse positions. Ranch and modern architectural styles led as the most popular, but were preferred by only 13 percent of survey participants each, followed by cottage and traditional homes at 9 percent each. However, when broken up by generation, baby boomers preferred ranch homes (20 percent), Gen Xers preferred ranch and modern (13 percent each) and millennials leaned toward modern homes (13 percent).
• On interior styles, homebuyers were split amongst transitional, traditional, contemporary and farmhouse at 14 percent each. However, baby boomers preferred traditional interior design styles (17 percent), Gen Xers enjoyed transitional (17 percent) and millennials liked contemporary interior design (16 percent).
• Custom built-ins and decorative ceilings were the top two design elements that future homebuyers would consider adding into their next home. And 38 percent wanted hardwood flooring in their home. Carpet is the most divisive interior home feature, showing up as the second favorite flooring option, but also ranked highly as one of the least favorite flooring options.

Builder preferences

• If a homebuyer is looking for a new construction home, it can be overwhelming to figure out which builder to go with. This is why 31 percent of survey participants said that a homebuilder’s satisfaction ratings are the main consideration that they take into account, above the ability to personalize their home (27 percent).
• And while homebuilders often provide community amenities, like a pool, and have partnerships with specific brands for materials and appliances, those were listed as the least important considerations for future homebuyers.
• In fact, homebuyers preferred builders that provide design personalization options (75 percent), and more than two-thirds said they are willing to pay more for that choice. So rather than providing community amenities, homebuilders may be better off providing professional design services, as 64 percent of survey participants wanted that option. Additionally, 78 percent wanted to be able to pick all of the materials – the finishes, colors, etc. – in one location as opposed to separate locations for each.